Riselabs
Book a call

Is it cheaper to keep a customer than to win a new one?

Usually, yes, though by how much depends on your business. The multiples you will see quoted have no traceable study behind them, so this page shows where they come from and how to work out the real figure from your own records.

Is it cheaper to retain existing customers than acquire new ones?

Usually, yes: a customer you keep has already been found, won and set up, and you paid for all of that once. How much cheaper it is depends on what you sell and how you win work, and no measured figure holds across businesses.

The costs of winning a customer come before any revenue. Someone has to find them, hold the first conversations, write the quote and chase it.

A customer you keep skips those steps. They know how you work, you have their details and their order history, and the next order usually takes less selling than the first. That is why the direction of the claim is easy to believe, even where the numbers attached to it are not.

How much more expensive is it to acquire a new customer?

No measured multiple holds across businesses. The figure you will see quoted, five to 25 times, comes from a 2014 Harvard Business Review article that gives it “depending on which study you believe, and what industry you’re in”, and names no study.

Source: Amy Gallo, “The Value of Keeping the Right Customers”, Harvard Business Review, October 2014 (US)

The same article quotes a second figure: that raising customer retention by 5% raises profits by 25% to 95%, credited to Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company. The article links to a 2001 Bain brief by Reichheld, and that brief makes a narrower claim: in financial services, a 5% increase in retention produces more than a 25% increase in profit. The brief gives no method, sample or data.

Source: Fred Reichheld, “Prescription for cutting costs”, Bain & Company, October 2001 (US)

Both figures are repeated far more often than they are checked. Read them as a long-held view that keeping customers pays. They say nothing about the gap in your own business, and that gap is something you can work out.

Why is customer retention cheaper than customer acquisition?

Because the cost of winning a customer is paid before they buy anything, and a customer you keep has already had it paid. Every repeat order arrives without a new search, a new first meeting or a new account to set up.

Much of the effort of winning customers goes on people who never buy. The calls, emails, meetings and quotes that come to nothing are spread across the few who do. The cold calling sums show how many dials it takes to book a single meeting.

Keeping customers costs something too. It takes account time, service when something goes wrong, and sometimes a better price to stay. A customer who costs more to serve than they bring in is cheaper to lose, so the sum is worth doing customer by customer rather than for the whole book.

A lapsed customer sits in between. They already know you, so winning one back skips the finding, but it means dealing with whatever made them go quiet.

Winning new customers is still the right call when:

How do you calculate the value of a customer?

Take the profit a customer brings in each year and multiply it by the number of years customers usually stay. Set that against what it costs you to win one, and you have the gap between keeping and winning for your own business, in your own figures.

You will see the result called lifetime value, LTV or CLV. Some versions are worked on revenue rather than profit; profit is the safer one to decide with, because it is what is left to pay for winning the next customer.

An illustration, with round numbers rather than anyone’s real figures: a customer who brings in £10,000 of profit a year and stays four years is worth £40,000. If winning one costs £8,000 in sales time and fees, every customer who leaves early costs that £8,000 again to replace, on top of the profit they would have brought. Put in your own figures; the shape of the sum is the useful part.

For the cost side, what a salesperson costs sets out a salary and its on-costs, and what lead generation costs gives the published prices per meeting. The same sum tells you the most a new customer is worth paying for: the profit they bring in over the years they stay.

Before you spend: the customers you already have

If you have been trading for a few years, some of the customers worth keeping have already gone quiet: orders that stopped, quotes nobody chased, enquiries that never got a reply. They are in your CRM, your order history and your inbox, and there is a guide to finding them yourself.

Before you spend on finding new customers, have you considered having me count the ones you already have?

Turn your old data into new leads.

Your team gets names and reasons from your own records. Nobody buys a list.

From £750 + VAT